A couple nights later, in youth service, I was talking to a girl that I really liked, and I knew she liked me back. I was struggling hard and the message was about giving your worries to God and letting him take control. I prayed for God to show me a sign for what I needed to do. After service was over, the girl I was talking to told me she wasn’t ready for a boyfriend right now. And now, 5 years later, I am in love with a very lovely and Godly woman (not the one I initially talked to, but that’s how God works). We have read other Joshua Harris books together and we have never been closer.
About Joshua Harris
He received no formal seminary or theological training until 2015, when he attended Regent College, Vancouver, B.C. Harris married Shannon Hendrickson in 1998. His brothers, twins Alex and Brett, authored The Rebelution (rebelution is a neologism defined by its creators as “a teenage rebellion against low expectations). Smart love manifests itself in courtship, which is simply dating with purpose.
I Survived ‘I Kissed Dating Goodbye’
If I go on too much longer, my fingers won’t be able to type for a while. Like I mentioned near the beginning, if couples who courted are truly happy that they did it…kudos to them. Josh Harris had good intentions, but I suspect this book has done more damage than good.
Sure, there are some couples who did the whole courtship thing and ended up marrying the love of their life. As long as they’re truly happy, who am I to tell them what they should have done? This story reminds me a lot of similar folk tales, like the Cinderella archetype, or virtually any other story about a young woman doing everyday labor, being kind to a stranger, and then being rewarded for it. There was one from my childhood about a girl who gave an odd little man something to eat or drink– in return he said she could harvest golden apples from his tree, but she’s the only one who can do it.
Courtship teaches that a man and woman should only “go out” if marriage was the goal. I’ve never turned in a Documentary Sunday review without watching the entire movie before. Every week, Megan Condis and a group of friends get together for Documentary Sunday, a chance to dive into the weird, the wacky, the hilarious and the heartbreaking corners of our culture. This column chronicles all of the must-watch documentary films available for streaming.
A successful hookup and a successful courtship are ones in which both parties can walk away without hurt feelings or any deep bond with one another. Harris’s framework for relationships fails, not simply because it is patriarchal or prudish, but because it does not address actual relationship mores. Our modern sexual landscape is riddled with problems.
Rather than admit their failing to the church community, the woman aborted the child. Despite marrying her fiancé and having more children, she grieved the loss of her first child. According to Harris, the woman’s pride led to the abortion and caused her years of pain. In a Washington Post article on Harris’s influence, Liz Lenz argued that purity culture taught her that her worth is in providing her husband with sex and babies. While other resources in purity culture may encourage sexual availability for the sake of large families, Harris’s article and books make little reference to children within marriage.
Though many of the guidelines and rules suggested in this book are helpful, and most have good reasons behind them, there seemed to be a lack of motivation for the heart. Ultimately it’s the heart that matters – you need to get your heart in the right place rather than just try harder to follow a list of rules. And I don’t think the author Lovestruck was saying to just try harder to follow a list of rules, but in part, he came across like that. Maybe part of the issue was that he may have assumed readers would already have the ‘right heart’ coming into it, since it was aimed at Christians. I just think many would have appreciated more focus on the heart behind wanting to pursue purity.
I have no problems with young people going out in groups but if someone thinks this will keep them from having sex, I have some oceanfront property in a corn field in Nebraska I’d like to sell you. I spent years of my life guilt-ridden needlessly due to this book. You’re ina great dating relationship, and you’re curious why anyone would choose not to date.
NFL MVP Patrick Mahomes says Christian faith ‘plays a role in everything I do’ ahead of Super Bowl
Harris’ call to return to old practices helped many families — including my own — recover structures to protect the virtue of young people in days gone by. The courtship movement may have been awkward at times, but I think we all took stumbling steps toward something truly good. At 34, I don’t always know what response I will get when I describe my sexual history. This was my first time at the clinic, and I wondered what my doctor would think.